
Church Discipline 101
1 Corinthians 5:1-13
Jesus has called us to be his disciples―those who are “mathetes”―apprentices—under the instruction of the Master to become as the master. This word is at the heart of the difficult subject we read about today: discipline in the Church. At the root of discipline is the idea of discipleship: to be a disciple is to be a person who is “disciplined.” This is true of our identity as God’s dearly beloved children. The writer of Hebrews tells us that God disciplines all of his children as a sign of his love, and he does this so that we “share in his holiness” (Hebrews 12:4-10). My guess is that if I were to ask how many of you wanted to be faithful disciples of Jesus and holy children of God the Father, the vast majority of you would wish to be so regarded. That kind of life is impossible apart from the discipline that God brings to our lives.
Flowing out from the same love and desire for holiness, Paul writes to the Corinthians about their need to exercise loving spiritual discipline in the Church. In fact, he is writing as a father to his beloved children. His letter has a “Don’t make me come over there!” tone to it that reminds us of the reality of “tough love.”
Three Characteristics of the True Church
-Word of God faithfully preached
-Sacraments of God faithfully administered
-Church Discipline faithfully applied
Two Extremes:
-Liberal Laxity
-Legalistic Perfectionism
One Membership Vow
-Uphold the Purity and Peace of the Church
* WCF XXX.3
I. Church Discipline has the Honor of Christ as its Chief Concern –
1 Corinthians 5:1-2
“For vindicating the honor of Christ and the holy profession of the Gospel…”
David’s condemnation was because he had given God’s enemies an excuse to blaspheme.
Public scandals left unchecked diminish the visible luster of the Gospel’s Light and the fidelity of Christ’s testimony through his people.
II. Church Discipline has Redemption of the Offender as its Chief Aim –
1 Corinthians 5:5
“Reclaiming and gaining of offending brethren and deterring others from like offenses…”
Born of love for all, the Church speaks and acts for the spiritual good of the offender
The Offender probably doesn’t see it that way – at least at first.
Handed over to Satan? The Prodigal and the Pig Pen
III. Church Discipline has the Welfare of the Whole Community as its Chief Necessity – 1 Corinthians 5:6-13
“For purging out that leaven which might infect the whole lump…for preventing the wrath of God which might justly fall upon the Church, if they should suffer His covenant, and the seals thereof, to be profaned by notorious and obstinate offenders.”
Tolerable Leprosy?
Just how many bugs does it take a ruin a good salad?
Seriously, how many heresies pave the way to the acceptance of the craziness we see today in evangelicalism and so-called mainline Protestantism? How many child abusing priests were left undisciplined resulting in the nightmare the Roman Catholic Church is currently suffering?
The Unseen Work of Sin
Becoming in practice what we are called by grace
In this case, grace means judgment.
Starts with each individual, approaching this table: “Judge yourself that you be not judged” – 1 Corinthians 11!
Clean the leaven out of my heart (Psalm 139).
Clean us from the sin of improper tolerance and licentious laxity.
Clean out the leaven of Governmental Laziness and Arrogance on the part of Leaders.
For the Honor of Christ and the Freedom of the Gospel, for the Peace and Purity of the Church, and for the Reclaiming of the Offenders, Church Discipline is no optional extra but a moral and spiritual necessity. If it is ignored, we condemn the offenders to loveless despair, the Church to the wrath of God, and the honor of Christ to the manure pile. “If the salt has lost its savor…”
Let us now come to the Table of the Lord embraced by the love of the Lord, the One who loved us so much he died to make us the children of the Father. Let us come grateful for our Father’s good and wise discipline in our lives that is yet another mark of his love for us, summoning us from the pig pen and clothing us with garments of grace, pure and clean. Let us be thankful for Church Courts that demand of our ministers doctrinal fidelity and personal purity. Let us come to the Lord’s Table and proclaim with undying thanksgiving the saving Cross of Jesus Christ.